What Is A Lateral Flow Covid Test And How Accurate Is It
People in England are now able to take the free rapid tests twice a week but experts have raised concerns
Everyone in England is now able to take a free Covid-19 lateral flow test twice a week, but experts have raised concerns about accuracy. We take a look at the issues.
Who Should Use At
The preferred choice for testing is a PCR test at a medical facility or testing site, Zehnder said. But if youre short on time or cant make it to a testing center, there are situations where you can use at-home tests, according to the CDC.;
Use antigen tests IF:;
- Youre vaccinated and have COVID symptoms.
- Youre unvaccinated and have COVID symptoms.
- Youre unvaccinated and do not have COVID symptoms and have been exposed to someone with COVID.
Do NOT use antigen tests and instead seek out a PCR test IF:;
- Youre vaccinated and do not have COVID symptoms and have not been exposed to anyone with COVID. If youre vaccinated and youre asymptomatic, theres no reason to get tested unless youve been exposed to somebody with COVID, Zehnder said. There should be a reason for doing the test. Even if youre trying to be considerate before meeting a cousins new baby, the best home option would be to try a self-collection kit to mail in, which will be far more accurate.
- Youre vaccinated and do not have COVID symptoms and have been exposed to someone with COVID. Fully vaccinated people who have been exposed to COVID-19 should wait three-to-five days before getting testedat a testing center or doctors office.
In short, at-home antigen tests are a good option for people who are symptomatic or know they have been exposed to COVID-19, Zehnder said. Theyre not so good if youre asymptomatic.;
Partially Vaccinated People Are Less Protected
One study looked at how effective COVID-19 vaccines are against symptomatic disease caused by the delta variant. They found that two doses of the Pfizer vaccine are 88% effective, but just one dose of the Pfizer vaccine was only 33% effective. That means partially vaccinated people in a two-dose series are much less protected.
Recommended Reading: Does The Covid Vaccine Prevent Covid
Where Are Lfts Used
Until recently the tests were used for mass testing in particular settings, such as schools. However, earlier this month the government announced that LFTs would be made available for all adults to take a test twice a week. The idea is that the tests will help pick up cases of Covid that may otherwise go undetected, for example because of few or no symptoms, and help prevent the spread of the virus.
Antigen Testing For Sars
Antigen tests are commonly used in the diagnosis of respiratory pathogens, including influenza viruses and respiratory syncytial virus. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has granted emergency use authorization for antigen tests that can identify SARS-CoV-2. See FDAs list of;In Vitro Diagnostics EUAsexternal icon.
Antigen tests are immunoassays that detect the presence of a specific viral antigen, which implies current viral infection. Antigen tests are currently authorized to be performed on nasopharyngeal or nasal swab specimens placed directly into the assays extraction buffer or reagent. The currently authorized antigen tests include point-of-care, laboratory-based, and self-tests, and they are applicable to people of any age. See;Table 1;for additional information about antigen tests.
Antigen tests are relatively inexpensive, and most can be used at the point of care. Most of the currently authorized tests return results in approximately 1530 minutes. Antigen tests for SARS-CoV-2 are generally less sensitive than real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction and other nucleic acid amplification tests for detecting the presence of viral nucleic acid. However, NAATs can remain positive for weeks to months after initial infection and can detect levels of viral nucleic acid even when virus cannot be cultured, suggesting that the presence of viral nucleic acid may not always indicate contagiousness.
Read Also: Does Pine Sol Kill Covid
How Do Different At
There are nine SARS-CoV-2 antigen tests from five companies now . These are variations of Abbotts BinaxNow COVID-19 Antigen Self Test, Access Bios CareStart COVID-19 Antigen Home Test, Ellumes COVID-19 Home Test, the InteliSwab COVID-19 Rapid Test from OraSure Technologies, and the Quidel QuickVue At-Home COVID-19 Test. Of these, the Abbott BinaxNow, Ellume COVID-19 Home, and Quidel QuickVue tests are currently available direct to consumers, without a prescription, in pharmacies and online.
The instructions that accompany all of these tests include a disclaimer that negative results may require additional testing for confirmation. For each of them, theres a small chance of false positive results, too.
We typically recommend getting tested three to five days after exposure.Dr. Matthew McCarthy, Weill Cornell Medical College
The accuracy of an at-home antigen test depends in part on test sensitivity , test specificity , sample integrity , whether one follows the manufacturers instructions exactly, the time since a persons lastknown or suspected exposure and/or their onset of symptoms, and ones viral load at the time of testing.
For a test to be considered for emergency use authorization, test makers must submit to the FDA clinical data demonstrating test sensitivity and specificity. Some independent studies have shown much lower sensitivity and specificity for some antigen tests, particularly when theyre used on asymptomatic individuals.
Availability: , Walmart
What Type Of Test Should I Get
If you are exhibiting a fever, cough, trouble breathing, or other COVID-19 symptoms, you should get tested, regardless of vaccination status, health experts advise. You should also get tested if you have no symptoms, but know you were recently exposed to the virus.;
A lot of this depends on access and what is readily available to you. We are thankful to have rapid antigen tests that are easy to find, but if you dont have symptoms, their sensitivity is limited and we know that 40% of people who are contagious with COVID are asymptomatic, Dr. Martinello says. A NAAT test is more sensitive, but a lot still depends on the quality of the specimen.;
Still, for the diagnosis of people seriously ill , doctors will generally use a PCR test, because false-negative tests might result in inadequate treatment. ;
If you are traveling, you might be required to get tested, too. The location you are visiting might require a certain type of test and approved testing locations as well.;
Dr. Campbell says a PCR test probably makes the most sense for travel. You want to detect the virus early, and the PCR test is the most sensitive for that to make sure you are not infectious for your trip, he says, acknowledging that many places require a negative COVID-19 test 72 hours before boarding a plane.
School and workplaces
For surveillance, such as at schools or workplaces, antigen tests work well, Dr. Campbell says.;
You May Like: Why Is Arm Sore After Covid Vaccine
There Is No Such Thing As A 100 % Perfect Test In Medicine
VIRGINIA COVID-19 rapid tests can deliver results in less than 15 minutes, but there are questions about their accuracy.
A new CDC study compared two tests that can detect an active COVID-19 infection: PCR tests and rapid antigen tests.
Researchers found that for those showing symptoms, rapid tests were right 80% of the time. That number is down from the reported 96.7% when the FDA gave emergency use authorization back in May.
In those not showing symptoms, accuracy dropped to just 41.2%. There can be false positives and false negatives too.
Weve known from the outset that the PCR is the gold standard, said Dr. Cynthia Morrow, the director of the Roanoke City and Alleghany Health Districts with the Virginia Department of Health.
Dr. Brooke Rossheim from VDHs central office said its not a complete surprise to those in medical field.
This is where its good to have more data, said Rossheim.
Nearly a year into the pandemic, doctors with Centra Health said testing is still a challenge.
Testing continues to be a moving target, said Dr. Christopher Lewis. We cant do RNA testing for everybody all the time because we frankly dont have the capability as a nation.
Researchers recommend following up a rapid test with a PCR test if youre feeling sick and it comes back negative or even if you feel fine and the results are positive.
About the Author:
Chances Of A Rapid Test Giving A False Negative
A examined the results of 64 test accuracy studies evaluating commercially produced rapid antigen or molecular tests.
The researchers found that the accuracy of the tests varied considerably. Heres a look at their findings.
Accuracy for people with COVID-19 symptoms
For people with symptoms of COVID-19, the tests correctly gave a positive result an average of 72 percent of the time. The 95 percent confidence intervals were 63.7 to 79 percent, meaning that the researchers were 95 percent confident that the average fell between these two values.
Accuracy for people without COVID-19 symptoms
The researchers found that people without COVID-19 symptoms correctly tested positive in 58.1 percent of rapid tests. The 95 percent confidence intervals were 40.2 to 74.1 percent.
Accuracy during the first week of symptoms versus the second
Rapid tests more accurately provided a positive COVID-19 result when administered during the first week of symptoms. The researchers found that rapid tests correctly identified COVID-19 in an average of 78.3 percent of cases during the first week.
In the second week, the average dropped to 51 percent.
Differences between brands
The researchers found a large range of accuracies between manufacturers of the tests.
Coris Bioconcept scored the poorest and correctly provided a positive COVID-19 result in only 34.1 percent of cases. SD Biosensor STANDARD Q had the highest score and correctly identified a positive COVID-19 result in 88.1 percent of people.
Also Check: How Do They Test For Covid Antibodies
How Accurate Are The Laboratory Tests Used To Diagnose Covid
: MIT Medical answers your COVID-19 questions. Got a question about COVID-19? Send it to us at;, and well do our best to provide an answer.;
How accurate are the laboratory tests used to diagnose COVID-19? I was wondering if someone could have a false positive due to having prior flu shots or for some other reason.
When we talk about the accuracy of a laboratory test, like the one used to diagnose infection with COVID-19, were actually talking about two different types of accuracy sensitivity, which is the tests ability to tell us when an individual is infected, and specificity, its ability to tell us when an individual is not infected. A test that is very sensitive is less likely to give false-negative results, and a test that is highly specific is less likely to give false positives.
Unfortunately, the test is not equally sensitive. If the specimen collection is not done perfectly, or if a patient is in an early stage of infection or already partially recovered from the illness, their nasal-swab sample might not contain enough viral material to come back positive. There are many stories about patients who tested negative soon after their symptoms began, only to test positive on a test done later. One case study describes a 34-year-old man who tested negative four times before finally testing positive five days after being admitted to a hospital.;
Some Rapid Tests ’99 Per Cent Accurate’ Epidemiologist Says
The rapid antigen tests are on-the-spot screening tests that detect proteins in the virus and, as the name suggests, deliver results within minutes.
Like a home pregnancy test, the result is reflected as a line on a paper strip, and you can administer it;yourself.;
They are much cheaper and faster than PCR tests and are currently used widely across Europe and the US, where they are sold in pharmacies and supermarkets.
In Australia, the tests have been used at the Howard Springs quarantine facility and are currently being trialled at some aged-care facilities in New South Wales.
But there has been resistance to using them more widely as they are considered less reliable than the PCR tests and can lead to false negative and positive results.;
Different brands of tests vary in accuracy, with the national medical regulator banning some kits for sale in the Australian market, saying they’re too unreliable.
But epidemiologist Mary Louise McLaws said some brands of the rapid test were more than 99 per cent accurate, and using them every day increased their effectiveness.;
She wants them rolled out across businesses, hospitals, schools and at state borders.
“They only take 10 to 15 minutes and they’re a fraction of the price,” Professor McLaws said.;
“You’ve got real-time results and then you could go onto the work floor knowing that you won’t place any of your mates at work at risk of COVID, and you won’t get COVID.”
Read Also: How Do You Catch Covid
What Are The Concerns
One concern is that those who receive a negative result from LFTs may still have the virus experts have previously said this means the tests should be seen as offering a red light rather than a green light.
But as the prevalence of Covid falls, the problem of false positives also becomes pressing. That is because the false positive rate refers to the proportion of erroneous positive tests out of people who are not infected, not the proportion of positive tests that are incorrect.
This is not a big problem when there is lots of Covid about, as the number of false positives will be far lower than the number of true positives. But when Covid cases plummet, the problem grows.
Look at it this way: if one in 1,000 tests mistakenly show up positive , then even if there is no Covid around, 10 people out of every 10,000 tested would receive a positive result. That could mean a large number of people are asked to self-isolate who do not have Covid.
This article was corrected on 16 April 2021. The announcement about the twice-weekly LFTs was made by the government, not NHS England.
Lucira Check It Molecular Test
How to use: This molecular COVID-19 test requires you to swab the inside of your nostrils, then swirl the swab into a small sample vial. The testing unit runs for 30 minutes, and then a light-up display shows if the test is positive or negative.
Accuracy: For people with symptoms, the Lucira test correctly gave a positive result 94.1% of the time. In the same study, the Lucira test correctly gave a negative result 98% of the time.;
Availability: Costing about $55, you can order the Lucira test at lucirahealth.com.
Recommended Reading: How Many Covid Cases Are Asymptomatic
I Tested Positivenow What
If you get a positive result from either a test-by-mail or rapid antigen at-home test, youre most likely infected. The CDC recommends informing a healthcare provider or local health department if your self-test results come back positive. Other healthcare providers may tell you to visit a testing site for a PCR test, Zehnder said. If your self-test has an app, report your positive result there, too. Isolate and tell your close contacts youve tested positive for COVID-19.;
But Should I Really Trust The Results
It depends. If you lost your sense of smell and have a fever and a cough and got two negative results on an at-home test, it could be a false negative, Zehnder said, so you should behave as if youre infected and get a PCR test at a medical facility or other site. If your self-test comes back positive, either contact your town or citys department of health or your physician who can tell you either to self-isolate or get another test.
At the end of the day, Zehnder said you should approach testing based on your circumstance. If youre not exposed to a lot of people and youre working at home and you don’t have contacts outside your family, you have to use common sense if youre fully vaccinated, noting that breakthrough cases among vaccinated people remain rare.;;
The bottom line is, at-home antigen tests are pretty good for telling symptomatic people if theyre infected with COVID-19. And that you can trust.
Read Also: Can Cats Die From Covid
Which Test Is Best For Covid
- By Robert H. Shmerling, MD, Senior Faculty Editor, Harvard Health Publishing
Now that were well into the COVID-19 pandemic, the steps we need to take to effectively control the outbreak have become clear: conscientious prevention measures like wearing masks, washing hands, and distancing; widespread testing with quick turnaround times; and contact tracing for people who test positive to help stop the spread. Combined, these are our best bets while awaiting better treatments and widespread vaccination.
Diagnostic Accuracy Of Rapid Antigen Tests In Asymptomatic And Presymptomatic Close Contacts Of Individuals With Confirmed Sars
You May Like: How Many Worldwide Covid Deaths