Does Wearing A Face Shield Protect Against Covid
PROTECTION? Commuters brave the rain with face shields protecting their heads from the heavy rain due to Typhoon Ofel along Quezon Ave in Quezon City on Wednesday, October 14, 2020.
There’s no recommendation from the World Health Organization and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to make wearing face shields a policy
Is it necessary?
Its time to discard face shields!
It should be optional, not mandatory.
After half a year of being required to wear face shields, in addition to face masks, when outside their homes, many Filipinos are asking the government to rethink the policy. It can be suffocating. It can cause accidents. Is its use scientific?
The Department of Health , while saying its listening to peoples concerns, also maintains that wearing both a mask and a face shield, coupled with observing physical distancing, can prevent COVID-19 transmission by as much as 90%.
We understand the concerns raised on the governments policy on wearing of face shields and we are open to dialogues in improving our health policies. However, the nationwide case trend is plateauing and not decreasing, Health Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire said.
She said the government can consider loosening up health protocols once there is a significant decline in cases and a large portion of the population have been fully vaccinated.
So, is wearing face shield necessary to protect an individual from COVID-19?
Virus can still enter
Are Face Shields Good For Everyday Use
CDC does not recommend wearing face shields for normal everyday activities or as a substitute for cloth face coverings. However, some people may choose to use a face shield when they know that theyll be in sustained close contact with others. In these cases, its best to wear a mask underneath the face shield and maintain physical distancing when possible. This will help minimize the risk of infection since face shields have openings at the bottom.
The CDC also says if face shields are used without a mask, they should wrap around the sides of the wearers face and extend to below the chin. The CDC does not recommend plastic face shields for newborns or infants.
Is A Face Shield Better Protection Against The Coronavirus Than A Face Mask
For many of us, its now standard to don a face mask to go to the grocery store, the pharmacy, or on public transportation. But some people are wearing another type of face coveringa clear plastic shield that covers their entire face known as a face shield.
In April, to help slow the spread of the coronavirus, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention advised everyone to wear a face mask in any public place where other social distancing measures are difficult to maintain. The CDC hasnt advised the public to wear face shields, which qualify as personal protective equipment and are often worn by doctors and health care workers in hospitals.
In a JAMA opinion article published on April 29, Iowa City doctors and public health experts suggested that the face shield was a better option than the face mask for various reasons. Face shields are easier to disinfect than cloth masks, and it’s easier to breathe while wearing one, the researchers wrote. Face shields prevent the wearer from touching much if not all of their face, while a cloth mask only covers the nose, cheeks, and mouth. Theres also no need to remove a shield when youre talking to someone, which people tend to do with a mask.
Recommended Reading: How Long Does The Cvs Rapid Test Take
Use Multiple Defenses Against Covid
While goggles and eye or face shields provide an added measure of protection against the spread of COVID-19, its important to diligently use multiple protective measures to stay as safe as possible.
These include frequent hand washing, frequent disinfection of surfaces , wearing a clean mask in public, and following social distancing recommendations.
SEE RELATED:Why face shields alone do not replace masks
Comparison With Other Ppe:
The European standards EN 166-168 describes the general requirements for face shields, goggles, and safety glasses regarding their eye protection function. Goggles and safety glasses provide similar protection for the eyes, but do not cover the mouth and nose, making a face shield the preferred eye-safety device for infection control. However, in a healthcare setting, eye protection devices, including face shields, are designed to be worn in combination with other protective equipment.
Compared with face masks, face shields have the advantage of covering the entire face, including the eyes which may be a route of infection for COVID-19, although the frequency of such events is unclear . Unlike face masks, face shields do not filter the air that is in- or exhaled. This allows pathogens that are exhaled in small droplets from the wearer to fly around the edges of a face shield, contaminating the surrounding air. Face shields also offer little protection against inhaled small airborne droplets, only efficiently protecting against large droplets, which are blocked by the visor.
Don’t Miss: Cvs Pcr Test For Travel Cost
Advice On Cloth Masks May Need To Change Says Expert
The use of N95 for the general public is most likely unnecessary, especially if social distancing can be maintained, said Dr. Teresa Murray Amato, chair of emergency medicine at Long Island Jewish in Queens, New York.
According to Murray, N95 masks are best in a healthcare setting for providers who will be in close proximity for an extended period with a patient who has COVID-19.
She added that as long as a surgical mask has not gotten soiled, wet, or damaged, it can be reused. However, the advice about using cloth masks will have to be reconsidered based on this studys findings.
The decision to wear a cloth versus a surgical mask had been made on personal preference, as the thought was that they appeared to have equal efficacy, she said. However, the recent study suggests that certified surgical masks may have better efficacy.
Murray pointed out that the good news is that vaccines will continue to decrease the need for masking, and that, we would encourage anyone who has not been vaccinated to talk with a trusted healthcare professional about any vaccine hesitancy.
She also advised anyone with concerns about the type of mask they should be wearing to consult with their doctor.
Why Plastic Face Shields Arent A Safe Alternative To Cloth Masks
- Face masks remain at the core of the CDCs recommendations for protecting yourself and others against COVID-19.
- However, plastic face shields do not provide adequate protection from COVID-19 when used by themselves as an alternative to cloth face masks.
- Wearing them along with a face mask is recommended as the best way to protect yourself.
All data and statistics are based on publicly available data at the time of publication. Some information may be out of date. Visit our coronavirus hub and follow our live updates page for the most recent information on the COVID-19 pandemic.
Although the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention continues to make face masks one of its primary recommendations for preventing the transmission of SARS-CoV-2 the virus that causes COVID-19 some people are turning to plastic face shields for protection as they can be more comfortable.
However, medical experts say a plastic face shield does not provide adequate protection from COVID-19 when used by itself.
Instead, experts recommend plastic face shields only be used as a supplement to cloth face coverings, not in lieu of them
Don’t Miss: Did Hank Aaron Die From Vaccine
Thousands Of Frontline Workers To Get Mk10 Face Shields
As of mid-April, 450 face shields have been deployed to the Brighams ED and operating rooms. Theyre also being used by intubation and code teams. Several hundred Mk1.0 face shields were sent to the ED at the Brigham and Womens Faulkner Hospital.
The Brigham-led team is further increasing production and plans to make several thousand more shields in the coming weeks. They will distribute shields to the front lines and other high-risk areas at the Brigham.
We have been making these face shields for the Brigham, DFCI and other Boston hospitals, along with our local community first responders and nursing homes, says Hodnett. Weve made and distributed more than 1,000 face shields to the community. My husband and I, along with a dedicated group of volunteers, have been assembling these shields and getting them out. Weve had huge support from our community and being a non-profit, weve been able to use donations to buy all of the supplies we have used.
The team is now researching ways these shields can be best sterilized and decontaminated. These face shields seem to remain sturdy and intact after 10 sterilizations using an ionized hydrogen peroxide, says Dr. LeBoeuf. Our hope is that they can be used indefinitely, making them non-disposable.
Coronavirus Face Shields A Quick Guide
A guide for health workers about when and how to use face shields during the coronavirus pandemic.
We aim to provide documents in an accessible format. If you’re having problems using a document with your accessibility tools,please contact us for help.
- When worn together with a properly fitted surgical mask, face shields offer protection from contamination to others, as well as to the wearer.
- Where face masks are not available, face shields may be used as an alternative. Face shields offer some advantages and limitations.
- Droplet protection directly in front of the wearer .
- The wearers face and facial expressions can be seen, which may be important when caring for some residents.
- Some types of face shields may be cleaned, disinfected, and reused .
- Provide eye protection that a surgical mask cannot give.
- Gaps to the sides and underneath the shield which may allow virus-laden droplets to infect mucous membranes .
Putting on a face shield
Removing a face shield
- At no time should the front of the face shield be touched.
- Take off other PPE first and wash hands before taking off the shield.
- Tilt your head forward slightly, grab the strap at the temple and pull forward and over your head.
- Dispose of the face shield safely if it isnt reusable or place the used face shield into a bag or container to be transferred/collected to an area where cleaning or mass disinfection will occur.
- Wash hands again.
Cleaning and disinfecting
Don’t Miss: Cost Of Cvs Covid Test
Clean And Disinfect Your Face Shield After Each Use
The CDC suggests referring to the manufacturers instructions, if available.
If there are no instructions available, they suggest cleaning with a neutral detergent and warm water to remove any visible soiling, followed by a clean water rinse.
They then recommend disinfecting the face shield, preferably with a chlorine-based solution. Alcohol can damage plastic and glues over time. In addition, it may remove any antiglare or antifogging properties.
Rinse again with clean water to remove any residue.
Air dry or use clean paper towels to remove any moisture.
At first glance, it might seem that face shields would be a good alternative for certain populations, such as those who rely on lipreading for communication or those who have difficulty breathing.
Unfortunately, Henningsen said research shows that face shields are only useful as a supplement to face coverings.
They should not be used in lieu of them nor should people believe they provide the same level of protection.
It will be fabulous when high-quality, clear face masks are readily available that permit us to convey the full range of human emotion and assist those who use lipreading in communication, she said.
If youd like to buy a face shield, there are a wide variety of retailers who sell them.
Henningsen suggested hardware and office supply stores, as well as big box stores, as your best bet.
Online retailers like Amazon and Walmart also offer plenty of options, she said.
Face Visors May Protect Wearer But Not Other People Against Covid
Public health experts not convinced of plastic shields benefits for general users
Face visors and shields could protect workers who have close contact with others against infection from Covid-19, but may not prevent the wearer spreading the virus, experts have said.
Linda Bauld, a professor of public health at the University of Edinburgh, said research was needed into the alternative forms of face protection before they could be recommended for general use.
Visors or shields are worn by medics in addition to masks for risky procedures in hospitals, and UK stores including Co-op, Marks and Spencer and Waitrose have offered them to their staff. A viewpoint published in the Journal of the American Medical Association last month suggested they may provide a better option than homemade cloth coverings as advocated in the UK and several US states.
However, Bauld said she was sceptical. The reason for having a visor which would cover the upper half of your face would be if youre regularly coming into contact with the public at closer range, and you might be exposed to somebody who is emitting those small droplets that were all aware are very efficient at carrying the virus, she said.
So I could see how in some retail settings and other environments they wish to do that, but I dont think theres any strong evidence that theyre something the public should be wearing on a routine basis. The key thing is to cover the mouth and the nose.
Also Check: How Long Does Rapid Testing Take At Cvs
Dr Birx: Masks And Face Shields Protect In Different Ways
The following day, on Fox & Friends, Dr. Deborah Birx, the White House coronavirus response coordinator, also recommended the use of face shields, explaining that masks and face or eye shields protect against the spread of COVID-19 in different ways.
She pointed out that masks are worn primarily to protect others, not the person wearing the mask. The mask reduces the spray of respiratory droplets from the mouth of a person who may not have symptoms of COVID-19 but is carrying the virus and can spread it among others.
On the other hand, eye goggles and face shields provide a physical barrier to protect the wearer from contracting the virus from others and the environment.
Face masks provide a second benefit as well, according to Dr. Birx: They may reduce how frequently a person touches their eyes and nose throughout the day, which also might help reduce the spread of the virus.
Zshield Wrap Face Shield
Traveler editor Stephanie Wu is a fan of ZShield’s Wrap face shield , which she has worn throughout a 16-hour flight. Unlike most shields, it extends up from the neck, rather than down from the forehead, meaning there’s no pressure on your head or indentations left behind. The design also allows for more flexibility in adjustment when sleeping or reclining, while still covering the sides of your face and reaching above the top of your head.
Don’t Miss: Cvs Testing Cost
Does Wearing A Mask Increase Your Co2 Intake
The fit of cloth masks and surgical masks isnt as good as it could be. When you breathe in or talk, the CO2 escapes through the mask. The small CO2 molecule can easily pass through a mask. The bigger the respiratory droplets that carry the virus that causes COVID-19, the harder it is for them to pass through a properly designed and worn mask.
The Mannequin’s Face Became Spattered With Droplets That Spilled In Around The Sides Of The Visor
Where things get difficult is with what happens to the aerosols when wearing a plastic shield.
Nearly all of the aerosols were coming around the side of the face shield and reached nearly the same distances as without wearing anything, says Echternach. These results are still to be published, but Echternach says they should serve as a warning for anyone relying on face shields alone to keep them safe as pandemic lockdowns are eased.
They are certainly not effective when you are in close contact with someone, he says.
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention appears to agree with him it does not recommend face shields for normal everyday activities or as a substitute for masks. The Swiss health authorities have also warned against using face visors instead of masks after an investigation into an outbreak of Covid-19 at a hotel in the canton of Graubünden revealed all those who were infected had been wearing plastic face shields, while those who avoided infection were in masks.
A face visor by itself can protect against larger droplets but is less effective if the virus is airborne
But the scientific evidence around the effectiveness of face shields is mixed. While Echternachs research looked at what happens when someone who might be carrying the virus is wearing a shield, other researchers have tried to assess how they might protect the wearer from other people around them.
Read Also: How Much Is The Pcr Test At Cvs
When To Get Tested And See A Doctor
Currently, there are no official guidelines from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention or the National Institutes of Health regarding when you should get tested if you believe youve been exposed to COVID-19.
The CDC does not have guidelines for when, but they do recommend contacting your local healthcare provider if you notice symptoms of COVID-19. Testing decisions are determined by state and local health departments and your healthcare provider.
When asked by ABC News when people should be tested, the window Dr. Fauci recommended was no earlier than three or no later than five or six,” since the incubation period for getting symptoms of the disease after being exposed to COVID-19 is about five days.
Whether or not you believe youve been exposed to COVID-19, see an eye doctor immediately if you show signs of conjunctivitis, as some types of eye inflammation can be vision-threatening.
Also, if you currently wear contact lenses, be sure to use caution and thoroughly wash your hands before applying and removing your lenses.
Better still, you may want to discontinue wearing contact lenses altogether and switch to eyeglasses during the COVID-19 pandemic. Doing so may help you reduce how frequently you touch your face and eyes during the day, and wearing eyeglasses may provide at least some covering to protect your eyes from environments that might contain airborne coronavirus.
Schedule an exam