Can A Rapid Test Protect You From Getting Sick
Not really. Rapid tests are more about protecting other people, not making sure you dont get the virus.
However, when people get tested before going to work, a party, school, or traveling, it helps protect everyone.
Rapid testing is particularly good to help stop superspreaders of the virus, Mina said.
For somebody whos really spewing out tons of virus and is very likely to infect a lot of people, then the tests are more likely 95% or 98% sensitive for those individuals, he said.
Are Rapid Tests Reliable
Rapid tests arent quite as precise as the PCR but that doesnt mean they dont work really well, said Sue Paish, co-chair of the Testing and Screening Expert Advisory Panel.
If these rapid tests are administered effectively and appropriately, those results are reliable, she said.
The reliability of rapid tests vary in part because the tests themselves arent all the same. Different companies make their tests slightly differently, and some of them arent approved by Health Canada, Miller noted. The ones that provinces are handing out for free, however, are approved.
Doing some background checking to ensure that the test youre using or purchasing has been approved by a regulatory body I would say that thats the best way to ensure that the tests that youre using are as reliable as possible, Miller said.
Studies point to a pretty big range in the efficacy of rapid tests. One CDC study showed one kind of antigen test, the Sofia antigen test, was about 80 per cent accurate when it comes to showing which symptomatic people have COVID-19, and 98.9 per cent effective at indicating which symptomatic people dont have the virus.
Accuracy was much lower when it came to asymptomatic people, with just 41.2 per cent accuracy when it comes to the positive results. However, the negative results were accurate 98.4 per cent of the time when used on asymptomatic people.
This Story Is Part Of A Group Of Stories Called
Uncovering and explaining how our digital world is changing and changing us.
Should we be swabbing our noses or our throats for at-home tests? Do rapid tests even detect omicron at all? Are PCR tests the only results we can trust right now?
Guidance about how to approach testing in the omicron era seems to be evolving by the day. A recent real-world study that followed 30 subjects likely exposed to omicron found that PCR saliva tests can catch Covid-19 cases three days before rapid antigen tests, which use nasal swabs. These findings, which have not been peer reviewed, follow the Food and Drug Administrations announcement in late December that, while they do detect omicron, rapid antigen tests may now have reduced sensitivity. But that doesnt mean rapid tests dont play a key role in our pandemic response going forward.
This is all confusing to a public thats been pulled in several directions over the course of the pandemic when it comes to guidance and testing. Long delays for PCR test results, a shortage of at-home rapid tests, and the wait for more definitive science about the omicron variant have all made it more difficult to figure out when and how to to get tested. Nevertheless, public health experts say that, as more become available, rapid tests will be an increasingly vital tool for diagnosing Covid-19 and reducing its spread.
We dont want the perfect to be the enemy of the good
Recommended Reading: Cvs Rapid Testing Price
When Should I Use A Rapid Test And When Should I Seek A Lab Or Health Care Facility Test
The key difference between rapid antigen tests and PCR tests is that rapid tests arent always sensitive enough to tell you definitively if you have COVID-19 what theyre better able to tell you is about your infectiousness and likelihood of transmission to others.
False positives with rapid tests are very unlikely if you receive a positive result, you very likely have COVID-19. If you receive a negative result on your COVID-19 rapid test, there is still a possibility that youve been infected, but a negative result suggests that your viral load might not be high enough for the test to detect the virus and transmit to others. This is why you should test yourself the day of gathering with others, to ensure that you have the most recent, most accurate reflection of infectious status.
You should seek a molecular test such as a PCR from a facility that provides lab testing, such as The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, if
Are Home Antigen Tests Accurate
Yes. At-home antigen tests are quite accurate, especially if you have symptoms, Hafer says.
Still, they have some limitations. Antigen tests are more likely to return a false negative if youre infected but you dont yet have symptoms. Thats because they might not be able to pick up the low viral load of an early or waning COVID-19 infection. But when youre symptomatic, antigen tests may be a reasonable marker of whether someone is infectious, May says, at least at the time they take the test. Note, however, that groups such as the Infectious Diseases Society of America have so far held that neither rapid antigen tests nor molecular tests can be taken as definitive proof of a persons infectiousness.
The likelihood of a false result on an antigen test also varies depending on the prevalence of COVID-19 in a community, . When theres little virus circulating in the area, a positive result on an antigen test is more likely to be a false positive, and you should confirm the result with a PCR test to avoid needlessly isolating yourself. However, when theres a lot of COVID-19 circulating, as there is in most places in the U.S. right now, the researchers found that theres a higher risk of a false negative result on an antigen test.
You May Like: How Long Does The Cvs Rapid Test Take
False Negative Results Have Caused Frustration And Even Heartache For Some People Who Later Got Back Positive Pcr Results And Now Fear They May Have Infected Others
Follow this story and more bysigning up for national breaking news email alerts.
Rona MacInnes, 54, was determined to do everything possible to protect her elderly mother as her family prepared to gather for Christmas in Pennington, N.J.
With her son returning from study in Dublin, MacInneshoped serial at-home coronavirus tests would catch a coronavirusinfection he might bring home. The college junior would take six rapid tests before the holiday, all of which returned negative results. But it would become clear only later after he had spent time with his grandmother that he had been infected the whole time. Several days after gathering for Christmas, he got a positive result back from the first available lab-based PCR test he was able to book.
The result floored and frightened MacInnes, creating fresh worries about her 80-year-old mother. The familyquickly booked an appointment to get a PCR test for her mother that came back negative.
Thankfully none of us have developed symptoms, MacInnes said.
One New York City woman who relied on negative rapid test results to go out with her friends on New Years Eve only to get back a positive PCR test result afterward said she believes the at-home tests offer a false sense of security.
Our data support the recommendation for repeat rapid antigen testing for persons at risk for covid-19 who have an initial negative BinaxNOW result, the researchers said.
What Are The Different Types Of Tests To Diagnose Covid
Unlike antibody tests, which look for prior infection, COVID diagnostic tests look for current infection with SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. They are broken into two categories: molecular and antigen .
A summary of their differences
Because the samples are, for the most part, collected in the same way for both, the differences between the two kinds of tests are largely in how theyre processed. Molecular tests are generally more accurate and mostly processed in a laboratory, which takes longer antigen testswhich are sometimes referred to as rapid testsare processed pretty much anywhere, including in doctors office, pharmacies, or even at home. You can get antigen test results in about 15 minutes, but they tend to be less accurate.
Health care providers typically rely on molecular tests, particularly when people have COVID-19 symptoms, whereas antigen testing is often used when quick results are needed or for general screening and surveillance.
Below, we take a closer look at the two categories.
Recommended Reading: How Much Does Covid Testing Cost At Cvs
What You Ate For Lunch Could Affect A Throat Swab
If your COVID-19 test requires a throat swab instead of a nasal swab, what you eat before getting tested could also influence rapid results.
Susan Butler-Wu, who directs clinical testing for infectious diseases at the University of Southern California, told Insider that coffee and Coca-Cola could cause false positives if you’re using an oral swab.
“You’re going to swab your mouth after you just drank your coffee, you’re gonna get a positive, potentially,” she said.
Anything acidic like coffee, soda, or fruit juices could “mess with the chemistry” of a rapid or lateral flow test. Butler-Wu clarified that this risk is pretty theoretical. One study found that false positives showed up when unexpected substances were directly applied to test kits.
But still, test sites and kits that involve oral swabs will warn you to avoid eating, drinking, and smoking for at least 30 minutes before the test. This advice might be familiar to folks in the UK, where rapid tests commonly require a throat swab in addition to a nasal swab.
You should also avoid brushing your teeth or using mouthwash before a throat swab, since good oral hygiene could temporarily wipe the virus out of your mouth and lead to a false negative.
How Do I Know I’m Doing An At
Its very important to follow the instructions from the manufacturer carefully. Read through the instructions and be sure you understand them prior to opening the test kit. Wash your hands and surfaces before starting the test.
If you dont swab the nostrils properly, you may end up with a false negative test, so again, follow the instructions in the kit. You may feel uncomfortable swabbing this deeply into your nose or the nose of a loved one, but swabbing is fairly quick, and doing it correctly will improve the likelihood of an accurate test.
Recommended Reading: Cvs Pcr Test For Travel Cost
What Type Of Test Should I Get
If you are exhibiting a fever, cough, trouble breathing, or other COVID-19 symptoms, you should get tested, regardless of vaccination status, health experts advise. You should also get tested if you have no symptoms, but know you were recently exposed to the virus.
A lot of this depends on access and what is readily available to you. We are thankful to have rapid antigen tests that are easy to find, but if you dont have symptoms, their sensitivity is limited and we know that 40% of people who are contagious with COVID are asymptomatic, Dr. Martinello says. A NAAT test is more sensitive, but a lot still depends on the quality of the specimen.
Still, for the diagnosis of people seriously ill , doctors will generally use a PCR test, because false-negative tests might result in inadequate treatment.
If you are traveling, you might be required to get tested, too. The location you are visiting might require a certain type of test and approved testing locations as well.
Dr. Campbell says a PCR test probably makes the most sense for travel. You want to detect the virus early, and the PCR test is the most sensitive for that to make sure you are not infectious for your trip, he says, acknowledging that many places require a negative COVID-19 test 72 hours before boarding a plane.
School and workplaces
For surveillance, such as at schools or workplaces, antigen tests work well, Dr. Campbell says.
Are Rapid Covid Tests Accurate And Reliable
In general, yes. But you should know that false negatives are more likely to occur early on with rapid tests than with laboratory tests, like PCR.
False positives are much less common. However, the chances of a false positive can vary by brand, ranging from one in 150 tests to one in 5,000, said Mina.
That said, if your rapid test gives a positive result, you should assume you probably have COVID and isolate until you follow up with another type of test, like PCR.
Rapid tests are about 30% to 40% less sensitive than PCR tests, and they are more accurate in people with symptoms than without symptoms.
In one study, a popular at-home rapid test had a sensitivity of about 35% in asymptomatic people and 64% in people with symptoms when compared with PCR, but was around 100% accurate when it came to people who tested positive for COVID, whether or not they had symptoms. In the study, there were only a handful of false positives, all in asymptomatic people but 47% were false negatives compared with PCR.
These are still good tests! Its not fair to compare rapid tests you can do at home in 15 minutes to a lab-based result that might be more accurate but takes a day or more to get a result, Mina said. You may just need to keep all that in mind when taking a rapid test and know that taking multiple rapid tests is part of the strategy.
Read Also: Cost Of Rapid Test At Cvs
How Do Home Antigen Tests Work
Antigen tests detect proteins on the surface of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that provoke your immune system to respond. Because they react only to proteins actually contained in the test sample, they can return a false negative result when virus levels are low, as is generally the case, for example, when someone is infected but hasnt yet started showing symptoms.
Thats in contrast to the molecular-based tests, including PCR tests, which detect the genetic material of a virus. These tests work by amplifying any existing genetic material present in a sample, by as much as a billionfold, according to Nathaniel Hafer, PhD, director of operations for the UMass Center for Clinical & Translational Science and an assistant professor in the program in molecular medicine at the UMass Medical School in Worcester, Mass. This allows these tests to detect extremely small amounts of genetic material in a sample, he says. This amplification step makes them highly accurate, whether or not a person has symptoms.
When Should You Order An At
Testing for COVID-19 is an essential public health tool that helps prevent the spread of disease.
The best time to order an at-home test is when a person develops symptoms. At-home testing provides a safe, fast option for people with symptoms of infection or who have been exposed to someone with COVID-19.
However, testing can also help people in high-risk professions keep their families safe. It also provides some reassurance for people traveling to see family members who may be at risk for severe illness.
At-home tests are widely available now and are easy to use, giving people who don’t have access to hospitals or clinics testing options.
The FDA recently updated its policies regarding COVID-19 tests, aiming to increase access to at-home tests. The agency believes that testing plays a central role in helping people return to work, school, and important activities, particularly over the holiday season.
Not everyone can obtain testing at a hospital or clinic, so at-home options provide improved access to COVID-19 screening.
Don’t Miss: How Long Does A Cvs Covid Test Take
How Do I Use A Home Antigen Test
The exact directions will vary by brand, so make sure to read them carefully before you begin. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends that you disinfect the surface on which youll be placing the components and wash your hands. Lay out all the materials in the test kit before you start the procedure, as if youre practicing the chefs technique of mise en place but for an infectious disease diagnosis instead of cooking.
The tests involve swabbing the inside of your noseand its crucial to do this part correctly, so that you gather a good sample. Directions generally say to:
Insert the soft end of the swab no more than ¾ inch into your nose.
Firmly and slowly swirl the swab in a circle around the inside wall of one nostril at least four or five times, for a total of 15 seconds. Repeat this process using the same swab in the other nostril.
You then put the swab containing your sample into contact with some component of the test, such as into a tube of liquid that youve unsealed or against a card containing a test strip. Once youve finished all the steps, youll need to wait for a result. Be careful about keeping track of the time, according to what the tests directions indicate. The results wont be valid until a certain amount of time, but theyll also become invalid if you wait too long. CareStart and QuickVues tests, for example, should be read 10 minutes after completing the procedure, but they become invalid after 15 minutes.
What To Do If You Have A Negative Rapid Test Result But Still Have Symptoms
If your rapid test shows that you dont have the coronavirus but you do have symptoms of COVID-19, its possible that you received a false negative. Its a good idea to confirm your negative result with a more accurate PCR test.
PCR tests are generally more accurate than rapid tests. CT scans are rarely used to diagnose COVID-19. Antibody tests can be used to diagnose past infection.
Recommended Reading: How Long Does Rapid Testing Take At Cvs