Global Statistics

All countries
Updated on June 23, 2022 1:32 am
All countries
Updated on June 23, 2022 1:32 am
All countries
Updated on June 23, 2022 1:32 am

Global Statistics

All countries
Updated on June 23, 2022 1:32 am
All countries
Updated on June 23, 2022 1:32 am
All countries
Updated on June 23, 2022 1:32 am
- Advertisment -

How Common Are False Negative Covid Tests

How Does This Happen

How common are false-positive and false-negative COVID-19 tests?

There was no single explanation for why false-positives occurred, explained Professor David Murdoch from the University of Otago.

One reason could be an infection with a related virus.

Speaking to general infections, Murdoch said sometimes a false-positive result occurs because someones had an infection where a related virus or bacteria caused a cross-reaction.

Bloomfield last year explained viral fragments from earlier infections tended to be detectable when someone got another respiratory infection. Inflammation in the throat from this new infection could result in the cells breaking down.

That then releases these fragments of virus that are detected, but it is also not uncommon to have a weak-positive and then a negative test.

There was also the possibility a false-positive indicated an old infection.

Murdoch said when weak positive results were returned, health authorities would investigate a persons movements, if they had contact with a case, and if they had any past, un-tested illnesses compatible with Covid-19.

The findings might prove that this case was indeed a false-positive rather than a missed historical case.

They might just be someone who really … doesnt fit. They’ve had no exposure, theres no-one else around them .

In these situations, it seems really unlikely to be a positive result, he said.

When dealing with Covid-19 cases, however, it could be quite difficult to definitively say a sample is a false positive. Usually it would be on balance.

How Common Are False Positive Results

To understand how often false positives occur, we look at the false positive rate: the proportion of people tested who do not have the infection but return a positive test.

The authors of a recent preprint undertook a review of the evidence on false positive rates for the RT-PCR test used to detect SARS-CoV-2.

They combined the results of multiple studies . They found false positive rates of 0-16.7%, with 50% of the studies at 0.8-4.0%.

The false positive rates in the systematic review were mainly based on quality assurance testing in laboratories. Its likely that in real world situations, accuracy is poorer than in the laboratory studies.

A systematic review looking at false negative rates in RT-PCR testing for SARS-CoV-2 found false negative rates were 1.8-58%. However, they point out that many of the studies were poor quality, and these finding are based on low quality evidence.

How Accurate Are Lateral Flow Tests

There has been a lot of debate around how accurate lateral flow tests are, and concerns around false positives.

There are two main ways of measuring the accuracy of tests sensitivity and specificity which are defined as follows:

Sensitivity: The ability of the test to accurately diagnose people who are infected with the virus.

Specificity: The ability of the test to accurately diagnose people who are not infected.

A recent Cochrane Review, which combined the results of multiple studies assessing the accuracy of lateral flow tests, found their average sensitivity was 72 per cent among people with Covid symptoms, and 58 per cent for people without symptoms.

This means for every 100 people infected with Covid, and displaying symptoms, 72 would show up positive on a lateral flow test. For every 100 people infected but not displaying symptoms, 58 would show up positive.

Therefore, a negative lateral flow test cannot guarantee you are not infected with Covid-19. This means if you have symptoms you should still isolate and order a PCR test, even if you test negative on a lateral flow.

However, the Cochrane data suggests the specificity of lateral flow tests is very high around 99 per cent meaning if you test positive it is very likely that result is true, and that false positives are very rare.

The lower the levels of Covid-19 in a community, the more likely false positives are, as fewer people will be returning genuine positives.

Recommended Reading: Did Hank Aaron Get Covid Vaccine

First Off How Does The Rt

Although in the age of COVID most people have heard of the PCR test, how it works is understandably a bit of a mystery.

In short, after a swab has been taken from the nose and throat, chemicals are used to extract the RNA from the sample. This comprises a persons usual RNA and RNA from the SARS-CoV-2 virus, if present.

This RNA is then converted to deoxyribonucleic acid this is what the reverse transcriptase bit means. To detect the virus, the tiny segments of the DNA are amplified. With the help of some special fluorescent dye, a sample is identified to be positive or negative based on the brightness of the fluorescence after 35 or more cycles of amplification.

Read more:The positives and negatives of mass testing for coronavirus

Fda Warns About False Negatives From Covid


Jan. 6, 2021 — The FDA issued a safety alert Monday about the potential for false results from a rapid COVID-19 test made by Curative Inc. False negative results, in particular, have been a concern.

âRisks to a patient of a false negative result include: delayed or lack of supportive treatment, lack of monitoring of infected individuals and their household or other close contacts for symptoms resulting in increased risk of spread of COVID-19 within the community,â the FDA wrote.

To reduce the risk of false negatives, the FDA emphasized the importance of following the testâs guidelines. Swabs should be limited to patients who have COVID-19 symptoms and who test within 14 days of when their symptom start, and trained health care workers should oversee the sample collection.

Also, a negative result doesnât rule out COVID-19 and shouldnât be used as the sole basis for treatment or patient management, the FDA wrote. Health care providers should consider retesting their patients with a different test if they suspect the Curative test gives an inaccurate result. Patients should also talk to their health care providers if they think they received the Curative test and have concerns.

The FDA also encouraged health care providers and patients to report problems with the Curative test, including suspected inaccurate results.

âThe FDA will keep the public informed if significant new information becomes available,â according to the alert.

Also Check: Can Breastfeeding Moms Get Covid Vaccine

The Main Reasons For False Positive Results Are Laboratory Error And Off


Two COVID-19 cases previously linked to Melbourne’s current outbreak have now been reclassified as false positives. They’re no longer included in Victoria’s official case counts, while a number of exposure sites linked to these cases have been removed. The main and gold standard test for detecting SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, is the reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction test.

The RT-PCR test is highly specific. That is, if someone truly doesn’t have the infection, there is a high probability the test will come out negative. The test is also highly sensitive. So, if someone truly is infected with the virus, there is a high probability the test will come back positive. But even though the test is highly specific, that still leaves a small chance someone who does not have the infection returns a positive test result. This is what’s meant by a false positive. First off, how does the RT-PCR test work? Although in the age of COVID most people have heard of the PCR test, how it works is understandably a bit of a mystery.

What causes false positive results? The main reasons for false positive results are laboratory error and off-target reaction . Laboratory errors include clerical error, testing the wrong sample, cross-contamination from someone else’s positive sample, or problems with the reagents used . Someone who has had COVID-19 and recovered might also show a false positive result.

How Do Lateral Flow Tests Work

The tests are administered in a similar way to PCR tests. You run a swab over your tonsils and up your nostrils.

You then combine that swab with a solution, and drip the solution onto a testing tray, which works much like a pregnancy test.

Check your device after 30 minutes and it will tell you whether or not you have Covid.

Recommended Reading: How Long Covid Live On Fabric

Are Certain Types Of Covid

Generally, rapid antigen tests are accurate for symptomatic patients, with 99.6 percent accuracy in positive test results, according to a March 2021 study. Most of the currently authorized antigen tests can return results anywhere between 15 to 30 minutes, according to the CDC. Their individual accuracy can vary slightly in terms of delivering false positives, says Charlene Brown, M.D., public health physician and advisor for Everlywell, an at-home health testing company, though it’s still very, very rare.

“Rapid antigen tests are useful if you need results fast, with results available in as little as 10 to 15 minutes,” says Dr. Brown. “However, they’re generally considered less accurate than PCR tests and may miss some cases. There is also a chance of getting a false positive due to the fact that no rapid test is 100 percent accurate. The accuracy rate varies among each specific test and can often be found directly on the test company’s website.”

Polymerase chain reaction tests had a 97.2 percent accuracy rate in a , with a false-positive rate of nearly zero. They’re typically most accurate about eight days after infection.

“PCR testing is considered the gold standard in SARS-Cov-2 detection and is generally more accurate than rapid tests,” according to Dr. Brown. “The accuracy of PCR tests varies, and often depends on when someone is tested.”

What Causes False Positive Results

How to avoid the false negatives of coronavirus testing

The main reasons for false positive results are laboratory error and off-target reaction .

Laboratory errors include clerical error, testing the wrong sample, cross-contamination from someone elses positive sample, or problems with the reagents used . Someone who has had COVID-19 and recovered might also show a false positive result.

Don’t Miss: How Long For Covid Results Cvs

What You Can Learn From The White House Covid

Kayleigh McEnany tested negative for COVID-19 last Thursday. She tested negative again on Friday. And on Saturday. And also on Sunday.

But she wasnt negative on Monday.

And that presents a quandary even if youre not the White House press secretary. What if you get tested because someone close to you tested positive, but your test shows youre negative yet three days later you arent, and, unlike McEnany, you have no idea you have COVID-19 because you dont get tested daily?

The recent outbreak among White House staff and other Republican officials can provide some insight on how to make ourselves, and our communities, safer. Thats because, experts told me, sometimes a negative test result isnt just a negative test result. Sometimes its just the first stop on the way to testing positive.

Those first few McEnany tests fall into the category of false negatives, said Bobbi Pritt, a microbiologist at the Mayo Clinic. She was infected, but the tests couldnt tell that yet. Nobody knows exactly how common false negatives are, said Steven Woloshin, co-director of the Center for Medicine and Media at The Dartmouth Institute, but they arent rare. In one study from China, between 11 and 40 percent of tests1 conducted on 213 hospitalized, COVID-positive patients in the first seven days of illness came back negative. Another paper, this one a review of 34 studies accounting for more than 12,000 patients, suggested a false negative rate between 2 and 58 percent.

Nasal Swab Diagnosis Often Return False Negative For Delta Variant Of Covid

Must Read

Yusuff Moshood

A Public Health Physician, Dr. Taiwo Obembe has cautioned against depending on nasopharyngeal swab tests when testing for the Delta variant of COVID-19, noting that it often gives false-negative results.

Obembe, who is a public health specialist at the College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, says there have been more false-negative results from COVID-19 nasopharyngeal tests in recent time.

The nasopharyngeal test is the standard testing method for the diagnosis of COVID-19 and is now widely used to diagnose severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 infection, which is the virus that causes COVID-19 disease.

It is also frequently used for the detection of various viruses and bacterial infections.

However, according to Obembe, this method may not be effective in detecting the Delta COVID-19 variant, because the virulent variant does not live in the nasopharyngeal area.

It is more virulent because this strain does not live in the nasopharyngeal region. It directly affects the lungs, which means that the periods are shorter.

Patients often present without fever, without pain, but report mild chest pneumonia on their x-rays.

Nasal swab tests are very often negative for COVID-19 Delta variant and there are more and more false-negative results from nasopharyngeal tests.

This means that the virus spreads and spreads directly to the lungs, causing acute respiratory stress caused by viral pneumonia.

Copyright PUNCH

Also Check: How Long Does Cvs Take For Covid Results

How This Translates

Hilborne describes a hypothetical scenario in which a drive-thru collection center sees 100 patients who are unwell enough to warrant a test.

Specimens are collected using a technique that has a 65 percent chance of picking up the virus. Of the 100 people tested at the drive through, 20 percent test positive. Thats 20 patients.

But what about the remainder who tested negative?

If the collection success rate is 65 percent, then there will be an additional roughly 10 to 11 patients who are infected but who have a negative test. That is, one-third of infected patients in this scenario who have the infection will test negative even though the test itself is analytically extremely good, Hilborne explained.

estimates that one person with COVID-19 will pass the virus on to at least two people.

Given this, experts say that if a person with symptoms receives a negative test result, they should still self-isolate.

If a patient presents with symptoms of COVID-19 cough, fever, shortness of breath but they test negative, they should self-isolate out of an abundance of caution to stop the potential spread of the disease, LeRoy said. The tests used are not 100 percent accurate and a negative test does not always equate to not having the disease.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention notes that even if a person tests negative, that doesnt guarantee they wont become ill.

What Is A False

Fever, loss of smell predict COVID

A false-positive or a weak-positive result was when a test indicated a sample was positive when, in fact, the person wasnt infected. This had everything to do with the cycle threshold value of the sample.

The CT value was the number of amplification cycles needed in the PCR test process to detect the virus in the sample. The lower the number , the earlier the infection, the higher the number, the older the infection.

The Director-General of Health Dr Ashley Bloomfield said in September when CT values tend to get around 30 you start to wonder.

If it is over 35 then you are pretty confident this is an old infection.

Also Check: How Long Cvs Covid Test Results

Reporting Problems To The Fda

The FDA encourages stakeholders to report any adverse events or suspected adverse events experienced with antigen tests for rapid detection of SARS-CoV-2.

Prompt reporting of adverse events can help the FDA identify and better understand the risks associated with medical devices.

Will Serology Tests Help Identify A Source

Serology testing are blood tests that look back to identify new or historical infections. These may be helpful in situations like this.

Murdoch explained serology tests identified historical cases through lingering antibodies after infection. Sometimes these antibodies only lingered in a recovered persons system for a few months.

So it was possible for someone to return a negative serology test even if they were in fact linked to an old cluster.

How long people remain positive for … is a bit of an art, Murdoch said.

None of these tests are perfect.

This story was originally published on June 19, 2021, and has been updated with information of a recent weak-positive test result in Wellington.

Don’t Miss: Did Hank Aaron Die From The Covid Vaccine

Even A Small Change To The Chains Can Dramatically Impact A Proteins Function

Maintaining an ideal pH for the antibodies is key to the correct function of the test, and thats the job of the liquid buffer solution that you mix your sample with, provided with the test. The critical role of the buffer is highlighted by the fact that if you mix cola with the buffer as shown in this debunking of an Austrian politicians claim that mass testing is worthless then the LFTs behave exactly as youd expect: negative for Covid-19.

So without the buffer, the antibodies in the test are fully exposed to the acidic pH of the beverages. And this has a dramatic effect on their structure and function. Antibodies are proteins, which are comprised of amino acid building blocks, attached together to form long, linear chains. These chains fold up into very specific structures. Even a small change to the chains can dramatically impact a proteins function. These structures are maintained by a network of many thousands of interactions between the various parts of the protein. For example, negatively charged parts of a protein will be attracted to positively charged areas.

Many schools in the UK have used regular lateral flow testing to check whether pupils might be carrying the Covid-19 virus

Children, I applaud your ingenuity, but now that Ive found a way to uncover your trickery I suggest you use your cunning to devise a set of experiments and test my hypothesis. Then we can publish your results in a peer-reviewed journal.

- Advertisment -

Hot Topics

- Advertisment -

Related Articles