Can I Get It Twice Herd Immunity Vaccines And Covid
Dr. Bill Moss, Professor and Executive Director of the International Vaccine Access Center at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health
As researchers continue to learn more about the novel coronavirus, a critical goal has been understanding how the immune system recovers from COVID-19, and how long any potential immunity might last. Recent anecdotes circulating in news and social media about individuals becoming infected with COVID-19 twice pose new questions for epidemiologists and immunologists as the scientific community works to develop a vaccine for the virus and as some speculate about what it would take to achieve herd immunity. To understand what we know thus far about immunity and COVID-19 â and where researchers are headed â we caught up with Dr. Bill Moss, Professor and Executive Director of the International Vaccine Access Center at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
What does it mean for someone to be immune from an infectious disease?
Once someone recovers from a novel coronavirus infection, are they then immune from the virus?
Obviously, thatâs not easy to do and it takes time. For one thing, the exposure part is hard to measure. One potential solution is to study healthcare workers because theyâre already at high risk of re-exposure due to their work. However, itâs hard to test and see if theyâve not been infected, and itâs even harder to show they were exposed but not infected.
Why Do I Need The Vaccine If I’ve Already Had Covid
According to a study from Kentucky that was analyzed in the CDC report on COVID-19 reinfection, people who previously had COVID-19 were about twice as likely to get it again if they weren’t vaccinated, suggesting that the coronavirus vaccines are very effective even if you’ve already had the virus.
“If you have had COVID-19 before, please still get vaccinated,” CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky said in August. “Getting the vaccine is the best way to protect yourself and others around you, especially as the more contagious delta variant spreads around the country.”
Weissenbach said that the strength of someone’s natural immunity from infection likely won’t last “over the long haul,” and that vaccination might provide better protection. This is because vaccines target a “particular reaction” from your immune system, he said.
“It’s done so in a very targeted and emphasized way so that it generally is going to be a more robust, lasting immune response than may otherwise be provided naturally through your body,” Weissenbach said. Think of it as a “double dose,” he said.
But research shows people who’ve already had COVID-19 strongly benefit from a single dose of a COVID-19 vaccine, which is not the case for people who haven’t been sick. According to an article in Nature, some people who’ve had COVID-19 and received just one vaccine shot mount immune responses equal to or greater than people who got both doses but never had COVID-19.
The Cdc Recently Changed Its Quarantine/isolation Guidelines From 10 Days To 5 Days What Are Your Thoughts On These Changes
Dr. Dumois: I would be concerned if the CDC put out guidelines and never changed them. The fact that they are changing recommendations and its based on changes in the science or changes in the culture, at least they are being responsive in trying to adjust to changes that are happening around us. When they dont change, then Im more concerned.
Also Check: How Much Does Cvs Charge For Covid Test
Are You Only At Risk Of Reinfection Due To New Variants Of Covid
New variants are a big concern for reinfection. Scientists are finding new variants that your immune system might not recognize. Worse, many of the new variants are more infectious than the initial COVID-19 virus. So there are definitely reasons to be concerned about new variants.
The question of whether you can be reinfected by the same strain of COVID-19, and how likely it is, is up in the air. COVID-19 is a coronavirus, and other types of coronaviruses that infect humans exist, usually causing mild cold-like illnesses. These other types of coronaviruses circulate throughout the population. Once you get infected, you are only immune for a year or two. After that, you can be reinfected.
Its not clear if the COVID-19 virus will be the same it will take time for us to know for sure. Its possible that we will see more cases of reinfection as time passes, because the protective immune response people get after the first infection with COVID-19 might disappear.
Some Parents Want To Wait To Vaccinate Their Kids Here’s Why Doctors Say Do It Now
The family’s bad luck was uncanny. Research suggests immunity against a natural infection lasts about a year. And here it was almost exactly the same time of year and the family was fighting COVID-19 again.
“Reinfection is a thing,” says Dr. Peter Chin-Hong, a specialist in infections diseases and professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. “It probably manifests itself more when the variant in town looks different enough from the previous variants. Or enough time has elapsed since you first got it, immunity has waned.” He says a second infection is still not common, but doctors are starting to see more cases.
You May Like: Cvs Pcr Test Cost
Will The Common Cold Give Me Immunity To Coronavirus
The jury is still out on the field of “cross-reactivity” but there may be some infections that look similar enough to the virus that causes Covid that people may gain some protection.
Laboratory tests show the T cells some people made to fight Sars or common cold coronaviruses can also react against the new coronavirus.
How common this is and how much protection it gives is still unknown.
How Strong Is Immunity After A Covid
About 90% of people develop some number of protective antibodies after a COVID-19 infection, according to the CDC. But how high those levels climb appears to be all over the map. Studies show peak antibody concentrations can vary as much as 200-fold, or 2,000%.
Where you fall within that very large range will depend on your age and how sick you became from your COVID-19 infection. It also depends on whether you have an underlying health condition or take a medication that blunts immune function.
Our immune system slows down with age. This process, called immunosenescence, starts to affect a personâs health around the age of 60. But thereâs no bright line for failure. People who exercise and are generally healthy will have better immune function than someone who doesnât, no matter their age. In general, though, the older you are, the less likely you are to get a robust immune response after an infection or a vaccination. Thatâs why this group has been prioritized both for first vaccine doses and boosters.
Beyond age, your protection from future infection seems to depend on how ill you were with the first. Several studies have shown that blood levels of immune defenders called antibodies rise faster and reach a higher peak in people with more severe infections.
You May Like: Cvs Testing Cost
How To Avoid Infection Or Reinfection
Getting the COVID-19 vaccine and any booster jabs will give you the best protection against COVID-19. While its still possible to get COVID-19 after vaccination , the risks of getting infected, becoming very ill, needing hospital treatment or dying are all much lower for vaccinated people than unvaccinated people.
You should follow the rules and guidelines in place where you live but also get into the habit of taking general steps to protect yourself and others. Whether or not youve had COVID-19 before, its important to try to avoid getting and spreading it even if youre vaccinated.
Steps you can take include:
- meeting people outside whenever possible
- opening the doors and windows to let in fresh air when meeting people indoors
- wearing a face covering in crowded indoor spaces, or where you cant keep apart from others
- limiting the number of people you meet and avoiding crowded places
- regularly washing your hands with soap and water
- using hand sanitiser when soap isnt available
- avoiding touching your eyes, nose and mouth when you havent washed your hands
- avoiding anyone who has COVID-19 symptoms
If you have symptoms of COVID-19, or have been in close contact with someone who has tested positive, you may need to self-isolate. This means not leaving your home and avoiding contact with other people for a certain number of days. You should check the government guidelines where you live for more details.
Check the latest UK government guidelines.
No Immunity From Protective Measures
Experts say the cases, isolated though they may be, are a reminder that COVID-fighting best practices still apply even after you’ve contracted the virus. “It’s important to note that there are people who do get reinfected, and in some of those cases you get worse disease,” said Iwasaki. “You still need to keep wearing masks and practice social distancing even if you have recovered once from this infection.”
As for yourself, do everything you can to prevent gettingand spreadingCOVID-19 in the first place: Wear your face mask, get tested if you think you have coronavirus, avoid crowds , practice social distancing, only run essential errands, wash your hands regularly, disinfect frequently touched surfaces, and to get through this pandemic at your healthiest, don’t miss these 35 Places You’re Most Likely to Catch COVID.
Read Also: Cvs Antigen Test Cost
What To Read Watch And Listen To About Coronavirus
New Scientist Weekly features updates and analysis on the latest developments in the covid-19 pandemic. Our podcast sees expert journalists from the magazine discuss the biggest science stories to hit the headlines each week from technology and space, to health and the environment.
The Jump is a BBC Radio 4 series exploring how viruses can cross from animals into humans to cause pandemics. The first episode examines the origins of the covid-19 pandemic.
Why Is Covid Killing People of Colour? is a BBC documentary, which investigates what the high covid-19 death rates in ethnic minority patients reveal about health inequality in the UK.
Panorama: The Race for a Vaccine is a BBC documentary about the inside story of the development of the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine against covid-19.
Race Against the Virus: Hunt for a Vaccine is a Channel 4 documentary which tells the story of the coronavirus pandemic through the eyes of the scientists on the frontline.
The New York Times is assessing the progress in development of potential drug treatments for covid-19, and ranking them for effectiveness and safety.
Humans of COVID-19 is a project highlighting the experiences of key workers on the frontline in the fight against coronavirus in the UK, through social media.
Coronavirus, Explained on Netflix is a short documentary series examining the coronavirus pandemic, the efforts to fight it and ways to manage its mental health toll.
Can You Catch Coronavirus Twice
Yes, it is clear that it is possible to catch the virus twice.
In the UK there have been hundreds of thousands of people who have tested positive for Covid twice.
Public Health England published data in June 2021 revealing there were 15,893 possible reinfections identified up to 30 May 2021 in England out of nearly four million people with confirmed infections. This is equivalent to around 0.4 per cent cases becoming reinfected.
Don’t Miss: How Much For Covid Test At Cvs
What Are The Symptoms Of Covid After Vaccination
The symptoms of breakthrough COVID-19 are similar to COVID-19 symptoms in unvaccinated people, but are generally milder. You may not notice any symptoms at all.
If you are fully vaccinated and develop a fever, feel ill, or experience any symptom that is not typical for you, getting a COVID-19 test may be a good idea.
For instance, if your allergies seem worse than usual or you experience a headache or mild cough when you normally dont have one, talk to your doctor about being tested for COVID-19.
If you suspect you might have breakthrough COVID-19 keep in mind that if you are infected, you can transmit the coronavirus to another person. While you are waiting to be tested or to get your test results, isolate yourself from others to the extent possible and follow coronavirus precautions such as mask wearing, physical distancing and hand hygiene to protect those around you.
What We Know About Natural Immunity To Covid
In terms of the immunity that’s built during infection , studies show that the vast majority of individuals who’ve recovered from COVID-19 produce all of the major components that facilitate immunity including protective antibodies and trained immune cells.
“For instance, a recent study showed that 98% of recently recovered individuals produce antibodies against the spike protein found on the shell of this virus. The study also showed that the levels of these antibodies seems to decline only a very little over the course of six to eight months,” explains Dr. Hiram Martinez, primary care physician at Houston Methodist.
Don’t Miss: How Much Is A Cvs Covid Test
Some Would Argue That They Dont Need To Vaccinate Themselves Or Their Child Because They Have Some Natural Immunity And If They Get The Omicron Variant It Wont Be As Bad Is This True
Dr. Dumois: It is not necessarily milder the next time. In people who have been vaccinatedyes. It seems that Covid is more consistently milder, but people who have not had the vaccine and theyve had Covid before, then their second episode might be milder, but it could also be more severe and put them in the hospital.
It’s Very Rare To Catch Covid
Some recovered Covid-19 patients catch the disease again
There may have been some rare cases of reinfection with Covid-19, but most people seem to be immune afterwards, at least in the short term
A few readers have asked us whether you can catch Covid-19 twice. This follows reports at the end of February that a Japanese woman had tested positive a second time. A recent article in the Daily Mail and twoarticles in the Sun also suggested in their headlines and their early paragraphs that this might be the case.
The evidence so far shows that catching the disease twice is very rare, and that most infected people recover and develop immunity against it. However, it is not yet clear how long this immunity will last.
When a journalist raised the case of the woman in Japan at the Prime Ministers press conference on 16 March, the Chief Scientific Advisor, Sir Patrick Vallance said: In any infectious disease there are cases where people can catch something again. Theyre rare. Theres nothing to suggest that this is a common occurrence in this disease, but we are learning as we go along.
A report from the European Centre for Disease Control and Prevention on 25 March says, there is emerging evidence from early studies suggesting that individuals develop antibodies after infection and are likely to be immune from reinfection in the short term.
Also Check: How Much Is The Rapid Test At Cvs
Second Infections May Be More Severe Why
This week, the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases reported on the first known death from coronavirus reinfection: an 89-year-old woman in the Netherlands who was undergoing chemotherapy for cancer. The woman became ill earlier this year, recovered, then tested positive for coronavirus again about two months later. She died of that illness after two weeks.
Scientists aren’t sure why reinfection happens, and why second infections might be more severe. Could it have something to do with viral strength, viral load, the patient’s overall health, or a mix? At the same time, it’s unclear how long the body produces disease-fighting antibodies after the average person becomes infected the latest estimate is around three months, although this is far from definitive.
So far, the data show that COVID-19 reinfections are not frequent. “If this was a very common event, we would have seen thousands of cases,” Dr. Akiko Iwasaki, an immunologist at Yale University, told the Times.
But the true number of COVID reinfections may be difficult to determine, because second infections, like the first, might produce no symptoms.
Until There Are Answers Play It Safe: Mask Up Wash Hands Avoid Crowds
Until scientists learn the answers to these questions, people who have been infected once shouldn’t assume they’re protected indefinitely, and should continue to wear masks, wash hands, maintain distance and avoid crowds, Shaman said.
“The only way we’re going to get a sense of it is over time,” he said.
Worthley admits she could have been more careful about wearing a mask. When she first caught COVID-19 in March, few people were wearing them, and Worthley didn’t know of anyone at church, work, her kids’ schools who had COVID-19.
In the summer and early fall, she wore a mask at work, but not at church. She assumed she’d be protected because she’d been sick for so long.
Now, Worthley said she’s not confident of being protected against the virus, so she always wears a mask.
“I have a whole bunch of them in my van,” she said.
Health and patient safety coverage at USA TODAY is made possible in part by a grant from the Masimo Foundation for Ethics, Innovation and Competition in Healthcare. The Masimo Foundation does not provide editorial input.
You May Like: How Much Is Rapid Test At Cvs
Yes You Can Get Covid Twice + More Omicron Questions Answered
The highly contagious Omicron variant is spreading in ways doctors tell us they never expected, fueled by holiday gatherings and traveland then there are the events that havent even happened yet as we head into New Years Eve and back-to-school.
Doctors are urging people to get their COVID-19 vaccine or booster if they havent already and to get their children vaccinated if they are eligible. This will give you the best protection against serious illness from the virus. You can read our in-depth Q& A with local doctors about the COVID-19 vaccine and your child here.
As we prepare to send our children back to school next week, we wanted to address some common questions about the latest surge with Dr. Juan Dumois, a pediatric infectious disease physician at Johns Hopkins All Childrens Hospital.
One big question we keep hearing iscan I get Covid twice? You betcha.
*Interview edited for space and clarification.